Since PHP's call_user_method and call_user_method_array are marked deprecated I'm wondering what alternative is recommended?
One way would be to use call_user_func, because by giving an array with an object and a method name as the first argument does the same like the deprecated functions. Since this function is not marked deprecated I assume the reason isn't the non-OOP-stylish usage of them?
The other way I can think of is using the Reflection API, which might be the most comfortable and future-oriented alternative. Nevertheless it's more code and I could image that it's slower than using the functions mentioned above.
What I'm interested in:
- Is there a completely new technique for calling an object's methods by name?
- Which is the fastest/best/official replacement?
- What's the reason for deprecation?
-
As you said
call_user_funccan easily duplicate the behavior of this function. What's the problem?The
call_user_methodpage even lists it as the alternative:<?php call_user_func(array($obj, $method_name), $parameter /* , ... */); call_user_func(array(&$obj, $method_name), $parameter /* , ... */); // PHP 4 ?>As far as to why this was deprecated, this posting explains it:
This is because the
call_user_method()andcall_user_method_array()functions can easily be duplicated by:old way:
call_user_method($func, $obj, "method", "args", "go", "here");new way:
call_user_func(array(&$obj, "method"), "method", "args", "go", "here");Personally, I'd probably go with the variable variables suggestion posted by Chad.
okoman : No problem... I was just curious ;) -
You could do it using variable variables, this looks the cleanest to me. Instead of:
call_user_func(array($obj, $method_name), $parameter);You do:
$obj->{$method_name}($parameter);
0 comments:
Post a Comment